This last week, I finally had a chance to try a recipe that I discovered in the Story of the World, Volume 1 Activity book…sand dough! You already know that we love salt dough, so I was curious to see how this compared.
It’s definitely messier to mix and a little hard on the senses (see note below), but it seemed to bake similar to salt dough and it painted well. We had trouble getting one of our thick pieces, a volcano that Josh wanted to make, to bake all the way through, but we had that problem with the salt dough last time, too. One of our thinner pieces broke. Because the piece didn’t seem thin enough to be terribly fragile, I’m not sure that the sand dough is as sturdy as the salt dough.
All in all, though the sand dough would probably work just as well as salt dough for a flat, immobile project, such as a relief map, considering the mess comparison, the ease of access of materials (it’s easier for me to pick up flour at the grocery store than to head to a home improvement or hardware store for sand) and the cost of materials (sand being a bit more expensive than flour), I’d probably choose salt dough. Sand dough would, however, be a viable alternative.